Centenary Book

Commonwealth Golf Club “The First 100 Years”
Foreword by Tom Doak
One of my favorite quotes about golf course design was written in 1929 by the English designer Tom Simpson, the godfather of minimalist design:
“The educated taste admires simplicity of design and sound workmanship for their own sake rather than over-decoration and the crowding of artificial hazards.”
As it turns out, the club secretary Sloan Morpeth was also a big fan of Simpson’s book, and used it as his guide when he rebuilt Commonwealth in the late 1930’s. This must be, in part, why I felt an instant connection to the golf course, on my first visit to Australia in March of 1988. The property is no different than anything else nearby, but the layout of holes provides great variety in terms of green sites, hole lengths, and tempo. The shaping and placement of bunkers and greens ensure that the golfer who knows his limits and executes the shots he assigns himself will have a great chance against any opponent.
When I listed Commonwealth among my favorite courses in the initial edition of my Confidential Guide to Golf Courses, I did so in part because it was the only great sand belt course not visited by Alister MacKenzie.
I always wondered how that could be, since the course was coming of age just as MacKenzie arrived. This lovely book provides the answer to that question, as well.
While MacKenzie was in Australia, Commonwealth’s major domo, Charles Lane, was in England for his own six-month tour to learn about golf architecture, spending time in the office of Harry Colt and visiting as many of the great links and heathland courses as he could. Lane’s trip sounds remarkably similar to the one I undertook after college, with a postgraduate scholarship from Cornell University, and I have no trouble imagining that he returned home as full of ideas as I did.
In the century since these great courses were built, some have evolved for the better, and others not. The one that has consistently improved is Royal Melbourne, thanks to greenkeepers like Mick Morcom and Claude Crockford and Richard Forsyth, and to club leadership who have not succumbed to the temptation to make changes to the layout. For the members of Commonwealth to truly appreciate the work of Charles Lane and Sloan Morpeth, you should show their golf course the same deference.
Traverse City, Michigan, USA
May 2020